Today's post deals with the so-called "Murderer's Row" Yankee squads of the late-twenties. Only three clubs collected more wins than the '27 Yankees (in a 154-game schedule). Of those three, none came close to matching the number of Hall of Famers produced by the Bombers. In that era, manager Miller Huggins had enough talented players sitting on his bench to give any team in the majors a run for the money. Statistics from the '27 season are mind boggling. At one point, the Yankees were 66 games above .500. They shut out opponents eleven times and won 43 games by five or more runs. They finished eighteen and a half games ahead of their closest competitors and held onto first place from opening to closing day. Talk about complete domination!
The problem with this chapter of my book was that it was a bit too long. As I said before, my original premise was to focus on the lesser known players who made significant contributions to their clubs. When my publisher asked me to concentrate on Hall of Famers as well, I was left with over a dozen thumbnail bios for this chapter. Four of those bios didn't make the final cut. All of them are worth reading (at least in my opinion)--especially Urban Shocker, a pitcher who might have ended up in the Hall of Fame if not for a congenital heart defect.
NEW YORK YANKEES
(1926-1928)
Number of Pennants: 3
Number of Championships: 2
Best Record: 110-44 (1927)
Hall of Famers: Miller Huggins (Mgr), Lou Gehrig (1B), Tony Lazzeri (2B), Babe Ruth (OF), Earle Combs (OF), Herb Pennock (P), Waite Hoyt (P), Leo Durocher (Utility)
OMITTED BIOS
Urban
Shocker
Pitcher
Shocker
began his career as a catcher at the semi-pro level. He logged his minor league
experience in Ontario with teams from Windsor, Ottawa and Toronto. Between 1913
and 1916, he assembled a 60-28 record on the mound. The Yankees acquired him in
September of 1915 then sent him to the minors to prove himself the following
year. He did exactly that, going 15-3 while stringing together 54 consecutive
scoreless innings.
Shocker
was used sparingly in his first two major league seasons. He showed promise
with a 12-8 record and 2.61 ERA in thirty-eight games. Before the 1918 slate,
he was traded to the Browns with four players and cash for Eddie Plank and Del
Pratt. Plank, a Hall of Famer, was forty-one years old and past his prime. He didn’t
even play that season. Pratt, an infielder, had three excellent years in New
York while Shocker became one of the most successful hurlers in the majors.
Shocker
was among seventeen pitchers allowed to throw the spitball after it was banned
in 1920. Before every offering, he would put his glove up to his face to give
the appearance that he was moistening the ball. As batters anticipated the “wet
one,” he would sneak fastballs by them. He employed the spitter mostly as an
out-pitch when he was in a jam.
From 1920-1924, the
slender right-hander collected more wins than any pitcher in baseball (107). He
peaked at 27 victories in 1921. After an off year in ’24, he was dealt to the
Yankees for three players, among them fading mound star Bullet Joe Bush.
Shocker
had a congenital heart valve defect. According to multiple sources, his
condition was so severe, he had to sleep sitting or standing up. Even as his
health began to fail, he pitched brilliantly, developing a reputation as one of
the craftiest hurlers of the era. In The
Yankee Encyclopedia, researcher Mark Gallagher remarked that Shocker was
“quite possibly the most courageous man in sports history. Urban bravely fought
in his last few years to play baseball and indeed for life itself.”
In
1926, Shocker won 19 games for the Yankees and recorded a 3.38 ERA. The long
season took a toll on him as he was only moderately effective in the World
Series, making two appearances and getting saddled with a Game 2 loss. He began
to show the effects of his illness more dramatically in 1927. Though he notched
an outstanding 18-6 record with a 2.84 earned run average, he made just four
appearances in June and later became too ill to pitch in the World Series.
Before
the 1928 campaign, he expressed displeasure with his contract and announced he
would retire to work in the radio business. He changed his mind, but ended up
making just one appearance before leaving the club. After his departure, he
pitched in a Denver exhibition tournament. It was a rocky outing. He later
caught pneumonia and was hospitalized. According to his wife, he was asking for
a newspaper to find out who was pitching for the Yankees just minutes before
his death. He was only thirty-seven when he passed away.
Ben
Paschal
Outfield/ Pinch-Hitter
Very
stern-looking in photos, Paschal originally came up through the Indians’
organization. In his first major league appearance during the 1915 slate, he
broke up a no-hitter with a pinch-hit single. It was Cleveland’s only hit of
the afternoon against Tigers’ right-hander Bernie Boland. Paschal ended up in
the Carolina State League in 1916 and the Central Association the following
year. When the latter circuit folded, he returned to his farm and was out of
baseball for two full seasons.
Joining
the Charlotte Hornets in 1920, he got another call to the majors—this time with
the Red Sox. Despite hitting .357 in nine September games, he was sent back to
Charlotte. Between 1921 and 1923, he was the Hornets’ most fearsome slugger,
peaking in ’23 with a .351 batting average and 84 extra-base hits. Transferred
to the Atlanta Crackers the following year, the Reds made him a generous offer.
Had he accepted, he almost certainly would have gotten a chance to play full
time. But in the end, the Yankees lured him to New York with a more lucrative
bid. Paschal logged twelve at-bats for the Bombers in 1924 and would stay with
the club for five more seasons.
With
Ruth, Combs and Muesel patrolling the Yankee outfield, Paschal watched a lot of
games from the bench. When Babe Ruth went down with a stomach ailment before
opening day of the ’25 campaign, Paschal got his first big break. In the season
opener against the Senators, he hit a 2-run homer in a 5-1 Yankee win.
Listening to the game on the radio, Ruth allegedly sat up in his hospital bed
and said: “They don’t miss me much.” Paschal was removed from the lineup when
Ruth returned on the first of June. The Yankees fared poorly that year,
finishing in seventh place, but it was hardly Paschal’s fault. He hit .360 in
eighty-nine games, including a pair of multi-homer performances.
In
1926, Bob Muesel broke a bone in his foot and Paschal got another opportunity.
He started thirty-four straight games from July 9 through August 11. He hit
.324 in July before cooling off a bit in August. After finishing the regular
season at .287, he appeared as a sub in five World Series games. His pinch-hit
RBI single in the ninth inning of the fifth contest tied the score in a game
the Yankees won in extra innings. Had the New Yorkers not squandered their 3-2
Series edge, Paschal’s clutch hit would have held more relevance.
Paschal
was little more than an afterthought in ’27. With Ruth’s 60 homers and Gehrig’s
175 RBIs, his presence went virtually unnoticed. But he made the most of his
limited playing time, hitting .317 in fifty games. With so many talented
players on the squad, his services were not required in the World Series that
year.
By
1928, it had become glaringly obvious that Paschal was never going to break
through as a full time player. His name was used as potential trade bait more
than once. In the end, the Yankees hung onto him through the ’29 slate, when
his average slipped to .208. He continued in the minors until 1934.
After
his retirement, Paschal left baseball almost completely behind. He worked as a
salesman in Charlotte, North Carolina and was reportedly very accommodating to
those who recognized him. He died in 1974 at the age of seventy-nine.
George
Pipgras
Pitcher
Pipgras
got his start with Madison of the Class-D Dakota League in 1921. He earned a
promotion to the higher ranks the following year, fashioning a 19-9 record with
Charleston of the South Atlantic League. He was property of the Red Sox in ’23
until a January trade sent him to the Yankees along with first baseman Harvey
Hendrick. Hendrick would have his best seasons in Brooklyn. Pipgras would
benefit from the big bats in the Bronx.
There
was no room for the right-hander on a star-studded Yankee staff when he
arrived. Pipgras made just 17 appearances in ‘23/’24 then was sent back down to
the minors to work on control issues. Miller Huggins refused to give up on him
and, in 1927, he was called up again. Making twenty-one starts and eight relief
appearances, Pipgras posted a 10-3 record. He faced the Pirates in Game 2 of
the World Series that year, going the distance in a 6-2 Yankee win. There were
some formidable hitters in the Pittsburgh lineup that day, including the Waner
brothers and third baseman Pie Traynor. By the time it came around to Pipgras’s
spot in the rotation again, the Yankees had swept the Series.
1928
was Pipgras’s finest season. He led the league with 24 wins and 300.2 innings
pitched. He also posted the lowest ERA of his career at 3.38. In the World
Series, Huggins handed him the ball in Game 2 once again. He yielded just 4
hits and struck out 8 in a 9-3 win. On his way to victory, he held Hall of
Famers Frankie Frisch, Chick Hafey, Jim Bottomley and Rabbit Maranville to a
combined 3-for-14 showing at the plate.
Over
the next four seasons, Pipgras would win 56 games for the Yanks. He appeared in
the ’32 Series against the Cubs, getting a tough Game 3 win. He coughed up 5
runs in 8 frames, but the Bombers spotted him 7 runs thanks to Babe Ruth and
Lou Gehrig, who belted two homers apiece. That was the infamous “called shot”
game. Pipgras retired with a 3-0 record and 2.77 ERA in postseason play.
In
his heyday, Pipgras had one of the liveliest fastballs in the league, but he
couldn’t always spot it. He struggled with wildness throughout his career,
averaging nearly four walks per nine innings. He was among the leaders in hit
batsmen and wild pitches several times. With a 4.09 lifetime ERA, it’s doubtful
he would have been as successful on a non-contending club.
Traded
to Boston in ’33, he broke his arm in a freak accident. While delivering a
curveball, he felt a bone snap. He began a rapid descent to the minors after
that. Pipgras later embarked on an umpiring career. He reportedly had a hot
temper and could be rather hasty with his ejections. In one game between the
Browns and White Sox, he ejected a total of seventeen players. One biographer
noted that he had a narrow strike zone, which made him a “batter’s umpire.” He
definitely enjoyed the job, commenting to a reporter in 1938: “I’ve had my
share of thrills during my years with the Yankees and Boston Red Sox, but I get
just as much kick out of baseball in the umpiring ranks. You don’t get any
newspaper headlines, but it’s great work nevertheless.”
After
quitting umpiring, he worked as a scout. He passed away in Florida at the age
of eighty-six.
Pat
Collins
Catcher
Between
1917 and 1929, Collins had five stints in the minors. He played for the Browns
on and off from 1919 through 1924, serving as back-up to the capable Hank
Severeid, who was among the best all around catchers in the majors during that
span. In August of 1925, Collins was dealt by St. Paul of the American
Association to the Yankees.
When
first-stringer Benny Bengough developed a sore arm in 1926, Collins assumed the
bulk of the catching responsibilities. He was up to the task, placing among the
league leaders in assists and runners caught stealing. He was pretty reliable
with a bat as well, hitting .286 in 102 games. Demonstrating patience at the
plate, Collins drew 73 walks during the ’26 slate for a dazzling .433 on-base
percentage. By late season, however, he had come down with a sore arm of his
own, prompting the Yankees to acquire his former teammate, Hank Severeid.
Severeid played in all seven World Series games, leaving Collins to serve as a
substitute in three contests.
With
Severeid’s release at seasons’ end, Collins returned as the Yankees’ top
catcher in ’27. He appeared in 92 games and hit .275 with 36 RBIs. He continued
to wear out opposing pitchers, accruing a .handsome .407 on-base percentage. In
the ’27 Fall Classic, Miller Huggins employed a rotating three-man catching
platoon that featured Collins, Bengough and Johnny Grabowski in that order.
Collins was the only member of the group to hit safely, going 3-for-5 with a
double in Game 4.
Huggins
maintained the platoon system during the regular season in ’28. Bengough went
down for a spell with a hand injury and the younger Grabowski saw a bit more
playing time than Collins. In a diminished role, Collins fared somewhat poorly
at the plate, hitting just .221. Bengough started all four games of the ’28
Series and Collins didn’t see any action until the late innings of Game 4. He
doubled in his only at-bat, finishing his career with a .500 batting average in
postseason duty.
When
Bill Dickey came up in 1929, Collins was deemed expendable. He was traded to
the Braves that year and eventually demoted to the minors. His made his last
professional appearance with the Kansas City Blues during the 1932 slate. He
developed a heart condition in later years and died in his Kansas City
apartment after attending an A’s game. He was sixty-three years old.